The Hacked E-Mails That Wrecked a Tribe’s Casino Dream

Long Island’s Shinnecocks couldn’t agree on the best path toward the development of a resort casino. The disagreements led to feuding and the feuding to conspiracy and skullduggery. The casino never happened. And one of the main culprits has gotten off light.

A former member of the Shinnecock Indian tribe’s Gaming Authority has been sentenced to three years’ probation in the hacking of another tribal member’s e-mails in the midst of an internal feud that doomed the tribe’s plans for a massive casino complex on Long Island.

Karen Hunter, who pleaded guilty to a single count of misdemeanor computer fraud, received the sentence from a U.S. District Court magistrate in Central Islip, N.Y.

The hacking dates back to February 2012 when, according to news reports, the e-mails were stolen from the account of Chuck Randall with the help of third parties that were paid to perform the break-in.

Randall was one of several tribal members behind a plan to develop a gaming resort with a hotel and other attractions at Long Island’s Nassau Coliseum. Their proposal was at odds with the Shinnecocks’ official plan at the time for a partnership with Gateway Casino Resorts, which the Randall faction opposed, contending it favored Gateway at the expense of the tribe. The e-mails were pilfered allegedly with the intention of discrediting Randall and opponents of the Gateway deal.

Speaking at Hunter’s sentencing, Randall told the court she “weaponized” his e-mails when she accused him and four others―two of them members of the now-defunct Gaming Authority, two of them tribal trustees―of intentionally trying to harm the tribe for personal gain, calling it “a blatant lie she used to deliberately fraud the Shinnecock Nation”.

He told the court she should have received a tougher sentence, describing her actions as “criminal” and claiming they “led to the upheaval of the Shinnecock Nation’s 221-year-old government, the disruption of tribal programs, the lost opportunity for the Nation to regain between 2,200 to 4,000 acres of our aboriginal territory, and the loss of a multibillion-dollar economic opportunity and tribal economic self-sufficiency for generations.”

“Your honor,” he said, “she did not just steal my personal e-mails. She stole the Nation’s future.”

**GGBNews.com is part of the Clarion Events Group of companies (Clarion). We take your privacy seriously. By registering for this newsletter we wish to use your information on the basis of our legitimate interests to keep in contact with you about other relevant events, products and services which may be of interest to you. We will only ever use the information we collect or receive about you in accordance with our Privacy Policy. You may manage your preferences or unsubscribe at any time using the link in our emails.